Low carbon school guidance report: Target Zero findings
Low carbon school guidance report summary: Target Zero Knowsley school BREEAM costs, carbon and structure findings.
Low carbon school guidance report results show a Knowsley secondary school could reach BREEAM Very Good for a 0.2 percent capital uplift while frame choice moved regulated carbon by less than 1 percent. The Target Zero programme issued the school guide first among five non-domestic studies, according to New Steel Construction in May 2010, and finished the programme in 2011, according to Steel Construction Info. The case building was Christ the King Centre for Learning in Knowsley, Merseyside. Cost methods in this summary follow the pricing conventions explained in our data and methodology.
What did the low carbon school guidance report test?
The low carbon school guidance report tested costed routes to lower operating carbon and higher BREEAM scores for one secondary school. Analysts reset the Knowsley building to Part L 2006 minimum performance before adding measures back. That reset isolated the cost and carbon effect of each upgrade. Energy modelling used the IES software suite with CIBSE Manchester 2005 weather data over a 25-year net present value period, according to Steel Construction Info.
The base-case school had 9637 square metres of floor area over 3 storeys and was completed in December 2008, according to Steel Construction Info. Its frame was structural steel supporting precast concrete floor slabs. Wall systems combined timber cladding with aluminium curtain walling and a terracotta rainscreen, and ventilation was mechanical. Capital construction cost was 22500 thousand pounds at Q2 2009 pricing, or 2335 pounds per square metre.
How much did BREEAM ratings add to school construction cost?
BREEAM Very Good added 0.2 percent to capital cost for the stripped-back school, while Excellent added 0.7 percent and Outstanding added 5.8 percent. Building Design reported these uplifts in April 2011. The percentages measured extra construction spending against the Part L 2006 base case. A related announcement about sustainable school guidance is covered in new sustainable schools guidance.
Full cancellation of regulated carbon with on-site low carbon technology cost 12 percent more than the base case, according to Building Design in 2011. The school study sits with other costed design studies in Target Zero research reports. Procurement teams can therefore separate a modest rating upgrade from a far larger on-site zero-carbon package.
Did steel or concrete change a school’s operating carbon?
Structural choice barely changed the school’s predicted operating carbon. Alternative structural forms shifted annual regulated carbon by less than 1 percent for the school, according to Steel Construction Info. Depth differences altered internal volumes and heat loss. Heating demand rose while cooling demand fell, leaving a small net effect.
The school’s building emission rate was 27.3 kgCO2 per square metre per year under Part L 2006 modelling. Predicted total operating carbon was 36.8 kgCO2 per square metre per year. The ratio was 15.8 tonnes of CO2 per year per million pounds of construction cost. Figures come from Steel Construction Info cost and carbon tables.
| School structural option | Description | Structure unit cost (pounds per sqm) |
|---|---|---|
| Base case | Steel frame with precast hollow-core units on precast concrete piles | 203 |
| Option 1 | In-situ 350 mm concrete flat slab on precast concrete piles | 182 |
| Option 2 | Steel frame with concrete slab on profiled steel deck on steel H-piles | 190 |
Steel Construction Info reports these structure-only unit costs at Q2 2009 pricing. The concrete flat slab option carried the lowest structure unit cost in the table. Frame selection still left operating carbon almost unchanged.
Where was most embodied carbon in the school building?
Much of the school’s embodied carbon sat in the substructure, and steel piles gave the best result there. Building Design reported this finding in April 2011. Foundation and groundwork quantities drove the outcome more than the upper frame. Carbon splits by element deserve attention before frame prices.
The actual Christ the King building held a BREEAM Very Good rating and accommodated 900 students on a 9 metre by 9 metre structural grid, according to Building Design in 2011. Ground source heat pumps with heat-recovery equipment served the Knowsley schools. Aedas associate director Rob Hopkins said of low-carbon school design: “Knowledge is improving very quickly.”
Low carbon school guidance report FAQ
How much did BREEAM ratings cost in the low carbon school guidance report?
The low carbon school guidance report found BREEAM Very Good added 0.2 percent to capital cost for the stripped-back Knowsley school. Excellent added 0.7 percent and Outstanding added 5.8 percent, according to Building Design in 2011. The figures applied to a version reset to Part L 2006. Buyers can compare these uplifts against current project quotes.
Did frame choice change operating carbon in the low carbon school guidance report?
The low carbon school guidance report modelled less than 1 percent variation in regulated carbon between steel and concrete options. Steel Construction Info attributes the finding to thermal modelling of the Knowsley school. Storey depths and internal volumes caused the small differences. Frame selection therefore mattered less than efficiency measures and heating plant.
Where was embodied carbon concentrated in the low carbon school guidance report?
The low carbon school guidance report placed much embodied carbon in the substructure of the Knowsley school. Steel piles gave the best substructure result, according to Building Design in 2011. The base case combined a steel frame with precast floor units. Procurement teams can request substructure carbon splits before comparing frame prices.
Which school did the low carbon school guidance report study?
The low carbon school guidance report used Christ the King Centre for Learning in Knowsley, Merseyside. The school was mechanically ventilated and completed in December 2008, according to Steel Construction Info. Analysts reset it to Part L 2006 before testing measures. That reset lets buyers compare each upgrade against a common baseline.