The Low-Carbon Build Ledger

An independent research publication covering sustainable building consumables, materials data, and low-carbon construction.

Sustainable school building guidance for low-carbon schools

Sustainable school building guidance from Target Zero (May 2010) details a costed Knowsley secondary-school model, BER 27.3, to cut regulated carbon.

Build Materials Research Desk

Published

Reports

Sustainable school building guidance uses a Knowsley secondary school

Sustainable school building guidance from Target Zero gives design teams a costed path for lower-carbon secondary schools in the UK. The first Target Zero guide covered secondary schools and was published in May 2010, according to New Steel Construction on 1 May 2010, within a programme funded by Corus and the British Constructional Steelwork Association for sustainable, low and zero carbon buildings. The school study used the Christ the King Centre for Learning in Knowsley as its physical model. Its base-case building emission rate was 27.3 kgCO2 per square metre per year, according to Steel Construction Info, accessed 16 November 2026.

The guidance models a three-storey secondary school in Knowsley with 9,637 square metres of gross internal floor area. The real building was completed in December 2008. The study team stripped it back to a base case meeting the minimum of Part L 2006 so added measures could be costed fairly. The worked scope matches the school building types summarised in the school guidance report summary.

The base-case structure was a steel frame supporting precast hollow-core concrete units on precast concrete piles. Walls used timber cladding and aluminium curtain walling over part of the envelope, with terracotta rainscreen elsewhere. The building was mechanically ventilated. These choices fixed the benchmark for later energy and embodied-carbon comparisons.

What did the base-case school cost and emit?

The Knowsley base case cost £22,500 thousand at second-quarter 2009 prices, equal to £2,335 per square metre. Cost plans in this section use second-quarter 2009 prices throughout. The figure covers full capital construction cost for the whole school. The pricing method follows the approach set out in the data methodology.

The base case carried a building emission rate of 27.3 kgCO2 per square metre per year for regulated emissions. Total operational carbon reached 36.8 kgCO2 per square metre per year. Annual operational carbon per million pounds of capital cost was 15.8 tonnes. These modelled values all rest on the Part L 2006 baseline.

Which frame and floor option cost least?

The in-situ 350 mm concrete flat slab had the lowest frame-and-floor cost at £182 per square metre. Frame-and-floor costs in this section use second-quarter 2009 prices. The comparison isolates frame and upper floors, not whole-building cost. Each option was developed to the same design stage and costed on the same basis.

Structural option Frame-and-floor cost (£/m²)
Base case: steel frame with precast hollow-core units 203
In-situ 350 mm concrete flat slab 182
Steel frame with concrete slab on profiled steel deck 190

The three option costs carry a second-quarter 2009 pricing date.

The base-case steel frame with precast hollow-core units cost £203 per square metre. The steel frame with concrete slab on profiled steel deck cost £190 per square metre. The base case was the dearest of the three for frame and floors.

How were energy and carbon savings ranked?

Each energy measure was ranked by 25-year net present value per kilogram of CO2 saved against the base case. The team built a dynamic thermal model in IES software and tuned it to just pass Part L 2006. All five Target Zero buildings used CIBSE Manchester 2005 weather tapes for consistency. Some efficient measures showed negative net present values because they saved money over 25 years.

Structural form barely moved school operational carbon, with predicted annual regulated emissions varying by less than 1% across options. Low-rise warehouse and supermarket cases varied by about 3%, mainly through internal volume. BREEAM 2008 ratings from Very Good to Outstanding were each given a least-cost credit route. The school study sat inside a five-building programme completed in 2011, whose later guides were noted alongside the Target Zero supplement.

The programme also studied a distribution warehouse and an out-of-town supermarket. It further studied a high-rise office block and a mixed-use office and hotel building. Distribution warehouses were due at the end of May and retail guides in July. Offices were due in September and mixed-use buildings in November.

Sustainable school building guidance FAQ

What does the sustainable school building guidance cover?

It covers costed design and construction routes for a lower-carbon secondary school in the UK. Published in May 2010 as the first of five Target Zero guides, it was funded by Corus and the British Constructional Steelwork Association. The study used the Christ the King school in Knowsley, stripped back to a Part L 2006 base case.

What was the cost of the sustainable school building guidance base-case school?

The base case cost £22,500 thousand at second-quarter 2009 prices. That equals £2,335 per square metre of gross internal floor area. The figure is the full capital construction cost for the Knowsley school model. It anchors every added-measure cost comparison in the guidance.

Which structural option was cheapest in the sustainable school building guidance?

The in-situ 350 mm concrete flat slab was cheapest at £182 per square metre for frame and upper floors. The steel frame with concrete slab on profiled steel deck cost £190 per square metre. The base-case steel frame with precast hollow-core units was dearest at £203 per square metre.

How does the sustainable school building guidance rank carbon-saving measures?

It ranks each measure by 25-year net present value per kilogram of CO2 saved against the base case. The team modelled performance with IES dynamic thermal software tuned to just pass Part L 2006, using CIBSE Manchester 2005 weather tapes. Measures with negative values saved money over the 25-year horizon.